Tuesday, December 30, 2008

David's TV review of "Dragons' Den"


For the past seven months I've been writing about the work of conservative commentator and activist David Horowitz on my blog Books In Depth. A summary of these writings and my objectives can be found here.

My first freelance article for Horowitz's website, Front Page Magazine, was recently published here. It's a review of the TV show "Dragons' Den" putting the program in the context of the recent political question of whether the government should bail out the Big Three automakers.

I've recently submitted another article to Front Page which I hope they'll publish soon. It is film related and I'll link to it if/when they run it. I hope to write more articles for Horowitz's magazine in the future. If I'm lucky then they'll like my film-related piece and I might be able to write more like it.

David's "Valkyrie" review


Right here. There's a reason why we don't see very many historically-based thrillers based on true stories. I think "Valkyrie" is a textbook explanation of why.

David's review of "Seven Pounds"


The holidays caused it to get posted a bit late but that's OK. It's right here. I propose a model for understanding the film that might help people appreciate it.

Sunday, December 28, 2008

Anthony Reviews "The Curious Case of Benjamin Button"

I have seen and reviewed The Curious Case of Benjamin Button.

Even though there are a few things that would make it much better, I still like the movie the way it is.

Sunday, December 21, 2008

Anthony Reviews "Seven Pounds"

I have reviewed the latest Will Smith drama Seven Pounds.

There are critics who say that this film is painfully slow for most of its running time. You can count me in that group as well. In my review, I attempt to describe, without spoilers, the experience of watching this film from beginning to end.

Monday, December 1, 2008

David's "Four Christmases" review



Here. Not bad, though definitely not worth a trip to the multiplex.

Monday, November 24, 2008

David's "Twilight" review



Here. This was an interesting one to write.

Thursday, November 20, 2008

David's "Role Models" review




Here. Not bad, though not great. B+. Pretty funny, though.

Sunday, November 16, 2008

Anthony Reviews "Quantum of Solace"

I have seen the latest James Bond movie last night and have reviewed it.

Surprisingly, I did not like the movie. I say this because I am a fan of the Bond series.

Wednesday, November 12, 2008

David's Review of "The Secret Life of Bees"



Here. Just because it's sentimental doesn't mean it still can't be good.

Disagreeing With the Majority

I'm sure you've all had moments where your opinion of a movie is so different from that of most other critics. You may love a movie that most people hated or hate a movie that most people loved. So to liven things up around here, I got two questions.

1. What is it like for you to have a dramatically different opinion about a movie compared with most other critics? How brave are you in reviewing such a movie?
2. Name at least five movies where your opinion was part of the minority, whether or not you've written a review for it.

Monday, October 27, 2008

David's "Saw V" review



Here. The series gets back on track with this one. It's not as good as "Saw" and "Saw II" but it's vastly superior to "Saw III" and "Saw IV."

Thursday, October 9, 2008

David's Blindness review



I liked it a lot more than Black Sheep and Cine Snob.

Thursday, October 2, 2008

Tuesday, September 30, 2008

Black Sheep's latest reviews

Hello fellow online film critics. Here are my latest reviews:

MIRACLE AT ST. ANNA

THE DUCHESS

DVD REVIEW: SEX AND THE CITY

Enjoy!

Clint Eastwood's "Iwo Jima" Films

Clint Eastwood directed Flags of Our Fathers and Letters From Iwo Jima, both released in 2006 as complementary war films about the Battle of Iwo Jima. I saw Letters in the theater a month after its general release and Flags just last night on DVD. I now have my own quick reviews of each film (Flags of Our Fathers and Letters From Iwo Jima).

Since each review focuses only on that film, I thought I'd post this thread to share my additional thoughts on these films when considering them side by side. If you have seen both films, I'd be interested to hear your thoughts. If you've haven't seen both films, check them out, because they're very good.

I really like the idea of separate but complementary films about different sides of the same war. After seeing Flags of Our Fathers, I could finally see how both films overlap in scenery, even though they don't share the same living characters on screen. The camera shots of American battleships approaching Iwo Jima are neat to see from each side. "Flags" shows the Americans as they're riding along while "Letters" provides a distant view from the caves where the Japanese are hiding out. Another notable crossover is a group of Japanese soldiers who commit suicide. "Letters" shows them performing the act while "Flags" shows their corpses as the Americans stumble onto them.

In addition, each film tells a different kind of story. When you think of war films, you think of the despair during the battles themselves. "Letters" focuses on that, and that's good because such a story is more dramatic when it involves the side who ultimately loses the war (though you could argue that everyone loses in any war). "Flags," on the other hand, talks about the victory of war, or rather the perception of it. If both films were about how soldiers on each side suffered, there's no point in watching both films because they would be about the same thing. Fortunately, if you watch one of these films, you have a reason to watch the other one. Best of all, the story for one country can apply to the other. In other words, all people are the same.

The only thing I want to comment on is which movie I liked better. Obviously, since I've given each film a 10/10, I like them both. Yet, I thought Letters From Iwo Jima had a much stronger emotional impact. Again, it's because the horrors of war are more vividly portrayed by the side who has more casualties. Plus, I like a war movie that presents the other side. It's the same reason I enjoyed K-19: The Widowmaker, a drama with Harrison Ford and Liam Neeson as Soviets on a nuclear submarine.

So do you have any thoughts on Flags of Our Fathers and Letters From Iwo Jima? It doesn't matter if you've seen one, both, or neither. Comments are welcome from anyone. :-)

Wednesday, September 24, 2008

David's "Igor" review



Here.

I'm hoping to review "Choke" this weekend if it opens here in Muncie. If it doesn't then I'll either do "Miracle at St. Anna," "Lakeview Terrace," "Ghost Town," or "Righteous Kill."

Sunday, September 21, 2008

Black Sheep's Director Series: Fernando Meirelles



In honour of the soon to be released, BLINDNESS, Black Sheep has gone back for a look at director, Fernando Meirelles recent accomplishments ... BLACK SHEEP REVIEWS' DIRECTOR SERIES: FERNANDO MEIRELLES.

I think this party needs to get bigger.

Hey everyone, I was thinking maybe we should invite more critics onto the blog so that we can keep more content and enrich the discussion a bit. Do you guys have any suggestions of people to invite?

Saturday, September 20, 2008

MSN Article: Criticizing the Critics

Sometime back, I made a blog post about whether film criticism is supposed to be about analyzing the artistic elements of a film, commenting about whether the movie is entertaining, or both. Well, I saw this MSN article today that also goes into that but in a rather sarcastic way. Maybe too sarcastic.

Anyway, check it out and share your thoughts. :-)

http://movies.msn.com/movies/moviesfeature/dvd/critics/?icid=MOVIES3&GT1=MOVIES3

Friday, September 12, 2008

Black Sheep is Burnt After Reading

I was fortunate enough to drop forty dollars on the North American preview of BURN AFTER READING at the Toronto Int'l Film Fest. I got to see the back of Brad Pitt's head; I got to sit on an ungodly angle to watch the film; and the Coens were as curt as they were at this year's Oscars. I had a fricking fantastic time! Anyhow, click below to read my Burn After Reading review.

BLACK SHEEP REVIEWS: BURN AFTER READING

Wednesday, September 10, 2008

David's "Traitor" review




Here.

I tend not to like thrillers. It's just a problematic genre.

Tuesday, September 9, 2008

David's "Traitor" review should be posted anytime

I submitted it yesterday and it's not up yet but I'll link to it as soon as it's up. I gave it a C.

Saturday, September 6, 2008

Jane's "September Contest Slam"

I'm being swallowed up by all the DVDs in my office, so I'm doing a September Contest Slam and giving something away every day in September. Call me crazy. Any links appreciated.

Jane's "Bangkok Dangerous" Review

Here.

Save this one for when you're surfing around at 3 a.m. some night.

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

David's Bite Size review of "Hercules"

Here.

David's "Disaster Movie" review

Please forgive me father for I have sinned. I gave a positive review to a Friedberg-Seltzer parody comedy. There must be something horribly wrong with me.

Here.

Friday, August 29, 2008

Jane's "Hamlet 2" Review

Jane's "Hamlet 2" review here.

Contest: Black Sheep Goes Postal

Hello all ...

Black Sheep is giving away a few Uwe Boll signed posters and DVD copies of the film that has a 3.7 on IMDB, POSTAL! If you or someone you know whats in on the contest, please refer them to this link.

Thursday, August 28, 2008

Black Sheep's Fall Foliage (Part 3)



Here it is, folks .. the last installment of my fall movie preview. Looking at November .. More specifically QUANTUM OF SOLACE, THE SOLOIST, AUSTRALIA, MILK and TWILIGHT. Well, more like laughing at TWILIGHT, really. Anyhow, be sure to catch Black Sheep's Fall Foliage: November.

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

Film Analysis or Moviegoer Experience?

When it comes to writing film reviews, there are two types of content to include. One is film analysis, in which the reviewer breaks the film down into its individual elements and goes into detail about each one. Another is moviegoer experience, in which the reviewer describes his or her emotions and thoughts going on during the movie. As far as I'm concerned, you pretty much need both to have an interesting review. Different film review styles may emphasize one over the other. Some critics have education in film and/or journalism and may be more capable to analyzing a film parts. Other critics may focus more on the experience of watching the film.

For me, I'm more in the latter category but I do my best with analyzing the film, even if it doesn't always go all the way. Keep in mind that I have no training in film or journalism. In real life, I have a science background but I love to write and watch movies.

This is just something I've been thinking about lately. I don't know if it's necessary to even discuss it, but I thought I'd see what you all think. So with that, what's your review style? Do you think certain ways of reviewing a film are better than others?

Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Anthony Delivers a Double-Dose of Ben Stiller

My latest reviews are of two movies with Ben Stiller, one in current release and one from ten years ago.

Tropic Thunder (2008)

There's Something About Mary (1998)

Monday, August 25, 2008

Saturday, August 23, 2008

Vicky Cristina Barcelona review forthcoming

My review of Woody Allen's new movie is coming soon. Just got back from seeing it today and I'm very impressed. I'm thinking an A right now.

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

David gives "Art School Confidential" a second look

Here.

Black Sheep's Director Series: Woody Allen



In honour of Woody Allen's 40th feature, VICKY CRISTINA BARCELONA, I give you HANNAH ANNIE MANHATTAN ... a look back at 3 of Allen's best works.

Oh, and I added a blog poll on the side of the site so be sure to vote for your favorite summer blockbuster!

David's Clone Wars review



Here.

Sunday, August 17, 2008

FYI - Blog Action Day

A friend just emailed me about Blog Action Day. She writes:

"Blog Action Day is coming around again on October 15th. Last year [the first year they did this] 20,000 bloggers took one day to post on a common topic -- last year it was the environment, this year it's poverty.www.blogactionday.org

I just registered Film Gecko and will likely do a list of films about poverty, starting with Madonna’s wonderful documentary about poverty in Malawi, www.iambecauseweare.com.

They list all of the blogs, so another good way to get the word out, too.

http://blogactionday.org/en/blogs

Saturday, August 16, 2008

Jane's "Clone Wars" Review

David - Sounds like we're on the same train of thought with "Clone Wars."

My review at Film Gecko

jane

David's Clone Wars review forthcoming

Just got back from "Clone Wars" and I'll be writing my review tonight/this weekend.
Here's what I'm planning for the letter grade (and a hint for the approach I'll take for my review):

As a Film: D
As (as it should have been) a Direct-to-DVD or first six episodes of a children's TV show: B

Thursday, August 14, 2008

Black Sheep looks forward to the fall


Morning all ... Here is my first attempt at a Fall Movie Preview. The series is entitled BLACK SHEEP'S FALL FOLIAGE and this is the first piece, looking specifically at September.

Wednesday, August 13, 2008

Jane's "Tropic Thunder" Review

Check out my review of Tropic Thunder here. Loved it.

Tuesday, August 12, 2008

Anthony FINALLY reviews The Dark Knight!

Well, I'm late, but it's about time. I've reviewed The Dark Knight after a month (I think it's a month) since its release. At least I can say that I liked it a lot.

Anthony's Film Review - The Dark Knight (2008)

"Pineapple Express" review and "Kids" review

Here and here.

Friday, August 8, 2008

"Pineapple Express" review forthcoming

Just saw "Pineapple Express." I'll probably be giving it an A- when I write my review tomorrow or Sunday. :-)

Olympic-Related Movies

In celebration of the 2008 Olympics, I thought I'd see if anyone has reviews of movies related to the Olympics that they wouldn't mind sharing here.

So far, I only have one.

Miracle (2004)

Wednesday, August 6, 2008

Bite Size Reviews of Amish documentaries

Here.

Bite Size Review of "Scarface"



Here.

New Bite Size Reviews

I offer bite size reviews of the films I re-watched while on vacation: Citizen Kane, Casablanca, Elizabeth, The Weather Underground, and Together.

Black Sheep Reviews PINEAPPLE EXPRESS

Written by Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg
Directed by David Gordon Green
Starring Seth Rogen, James Franco, Danny McBride and Rosie Perez


Private Miller: I feel like a slice of butter melting all over a big ol’ pile of flapjacks … yeah.

I’m pretty sure my mother always told me that smoking pot was bad for you. She’s my mother so, naturally, I always believed her. Now, I’m not so sure though. She couldn’t possibly have seen PINEAPPLE EXPRESS before making this assertion. If she had, then she would know that smoking only leads to hilarity and kinship. At least that is one of the many valuable life lessons I learned while watching the latest Seth Rogen vehicle to come off the Judd Apatow assembly line. I also learned that paranoia can be a very good thing, that friends who smoke together stay together and that James Franco actually has a drastically different side to his usual stoic, dry presence. I think most importantly though, I learned that stoner movies, when they’re done right like this one, don’t require the audience to smoke up heavily beforehand in order to have a good time. Albeit, I’m sure a whole other kind of good time would be had if you did.


You could see this movie as an opportunity for Rogen to push his pot smoking agenda onto unsuspecting youths that think of his as some sort of demi-God after last year’s one-two punch, KNOCKED UP and SUPERBAD, or you could just drop the act and enjoy the trip. Besides, smoking is hardly over glorified in this film. Every time Rogen, as Dale Denton, a crafty process server, lights up, he finds himself in a whole heap of trouble. He makes stupid mistakes that lead to his deeper and deeper into despair. And while watching Rogen alone is certainly entertaining, watching him get goofy with a buddy is even better. The buddy here is the unexpected Franco. Franco plays Saul Silver, the drug dealer to Dale’s drug doer. Get these two in a forest and give them a little herbal amusement and there is no telling how stupid they will get and how far out in space their minds will go. There is one sure thing though, weed brings these two together and their lives are better for it.


Thank goodness these two have each other because they could never endure what they need to go through all alone. Saul sells Dale some of his highest-grade bud, called pineapple express. It’s so rare, so exclusive, that after Dale witness a homicide and dumps his roach at the scene, he believes that it can be tracked back to him. Saul must then get involved as he is the sole distributor of pineapple express and therefore the whole thing can be traced back to him. In order to get out of their unfortunate bind, the two must go to the source and get the bad guys, including a feisty Rosie Perez as a crooked cop, before the bad guys, and gals, get them. Many a stoner has inhaled and embarked on zany adventures before these two but how many find themselves in high speed car chases or live-or-die bang-up’s or even fleeing scenes of explosive proportions? Well, I can’t say actually but I can say that none have been this funny in what feels like a very long time (what feels even longer if you actually are stoned).


Dale and Saul are the new stoner buddies, the new Harold & Kumar, if you will. They are accidental action heroes whose pot smoking both gets them in and out of trouble. Unlike the punks responsible for the most recent Harold & Kumar disaster, the people behind PINEAPPLE EXPRESS are actually interested in making a solid film, one with an engaging story and consistent character development. Director David Gordon Green (SNOW ANGELS) knows that just because his characters are stoned out of their heads 99% of the time does not mean his audience will be necessarily. The audience might want to shut off and have a great time, either naturally or enhanced naturally, and that does not mean that you don’t actually have to try. When I want to shut off, I like to be around good people and let the laughs roll. Watching PINEAPPLE EXPRESS is like hanging out with the guys and I already want to hang out with these guys again next weekend.

GRADE: B

Tuesday, August 5, 2008

PG-13 Violence

This question is mainly directed toward Jane since she writes a column on family movie reviews.

In general I tend to not have a problem with violence in cinema. Whether it be the gore of the "Saw"/"Hostel" genre or the stylized action of a "Kill Bill"/"Wanted" genre I'm not one to wag my finger at filmmakers. I'm quite the opposite, I tend to be almost an apologist for such genres, explaining how the violence of hardcore horror films is used to generate a primal, almost animalistic, instinctual reaction in the viewer and the violence of some action films can be interpreted and appreciated as one would consider a dance. (The genre pioneered by John Woo is called "bullet ballet" for a reason.)

Where I see a moral question is rather in the violence in PG-13 films. I remember when I saw the first "Mummy" movie and being somewhat taken aback by the amount of violence and the number of people killed. The thing that bothers me is when we have violence without consequences taken in by children and adolescents. If you're an adult then you have the mental capacity and responsibility to understand what you're seeing. Not so if you're a child.

Now this isn't the filmmaker's responsibility, it's obviously the parent's. And the libertarian in me doesn't want to see any kind of government or authoritarian "solution" to the problem that would end up restricting or chilling filmmakers as artists. And part of me even questions how big of a problem it really is. Anyway... Thoughts?

Two Retro Reviews

I normally would not announce reviews of old movies that I've written. Today, though, is an exception just because the two retrospective reviews I've done tonight were of good films. :-)

Fargo (1996)

Contact (1997)

Sunday, August 3, 2008

Jane's "Flash of Genius" Review

This is pretty cool. Had the opportunity to screen "Flash of Genius" at the Traverse City Film Festival today. It doesn't hit theaters until October, so I'll have the first review on IMDB.com. I don't think that's ever happened before. Just listed it, but probably won't show up for a day or two.

Here's the review (I loved it):
http://www.filmgecko.com/flash-of-genius-review-traverse-city-film-festival/

And if anyone's on Digg, appreciate any Diggs or Stumbles:
http://digg.com/movies/Flash_of_Genius_Review_Film_Gecko

jane

Saturday, August 2, 2008

Next review: the new Mummy movie

Just saw the new Mummy movie, I'm writing the review now. It's clearly the best in the series, that's not saying much, though.

David Swindle's Cinema Diary Volume 1

Hey everyone, I told you I was working on something big film criticism-wise. Here's a link to the first volume of my collected reviews. It includes all the reviews I wrote for WTHR from May '06 to April '08. Also included are some thoughts on my critical biases and philosophy on film ratings. I'd very much appreciate any of your thoughts. :-)

Wednesday, July 30, 2008

Jane's Bitch Slap interview and Anthony's Critic review

Jane, I enjoyed your Bitch Slap interview. As soon as I saw the poster I thought of "Grindhouse." I'm surprised that they're going in that direction since "Grindhouse" did so poorly at the box office. Often it seems like if one kind of movie fails then studios will be afraid to touch other properties like it.

Anthony I share your fondness for "The Critic." I think a lot of what it's doing we see being done now on "Family Guy," a show for which I have a lot of mixed feelings. (Sometimes I love it, other times I just loath it.)

Tuesday, July 29, 2008

"Step Brothers" review

Here.

P.S. I'm almost done with something big film-criticism wise and you guys will be the first to know about it. :-)

Non-Film Reviews

Being a film critic is fun for the same reason as being a food critic, book critic, or any kind of critic. There's a sense of satisfaction when you express what you think and additional satisfaction when it makes a difference in someone's decision to try something. For me, my web site is a film review site, but because of this enjoyment of saying what I think of anything, my site has a section called "Other Reviews" where I put in miscellaneous reviews of TV shows, video games, and anything that is "film-like." It's obviously not the main area os the site but I have it in case anyone is interested in a little extra stuff.

With that, I'd like to present my latest non-film review: the short-lived TV animated show called The Critic.

http://www.anthonysfilmreview.com/Other/The_Critic.htm

I am sharing this as a dedication to us and other film critics out there. In addition, in case you haven't heard, the popular film review show Ebert and Roeper will be ending soon because neither critic will continue the show. It made me think of Siskel and Ebert, which then made me think of The Critic. :-)

(Note: As an advance notice, I will finally see The Dark Knight with a friend this weekend because he'll finally be free that time. I will post my review of it likely next Monday.)

Monday, July 28, 2008

Jane's Interview with the "Bitch Slap" Girls

These girls were fun. Caught up with them the day before they started handing out Bitch Slap swag at Comic-Con.

http://www.filmgecko.com/exclusive-the-bitch-slap-girls-interview/

Sunday, July 27, 2008

Back from vacation, "Step Brothers" review forthcoming

Hey everyone. Sorry I haven't posted anything the past couple days. My beloved and I took a vacation down to Patoka lake in Southern Indiana. I was without TV, internet, and even cell phone. It was wonderful.

I'll be leaving in about 20 minutes to go see the new Will Ferrell movie and be doing my review on that this week. I've also got a few blog posts to get out of me. Hope you've all been well.

Saturday, July 26, 2008

Jane's X-Files Review

Posted my X-Files review. Disappointing...

http://www.filmgecko.com/the-x-files-i-want-to-believe-review/

jane

Tuesday, July 22, 2008

Links From Anthony's Film Review

Ladies and gentleman, I've updated my site with links to all of your sites from the links page at my site (http://www.anthonysfilmreview.com/Links.htm). I have links to David Swindle's reviews, CineSnob.net, MoonStar Film Reviews, Black Sheep Reviews, Reel Life With Jane, and Salty Popcorn. If I missed anyone and you want to be listed, let me know. Also, if there is an error in my description of your site, let me know as well.

Sunday, July 20, 2008

Jane's Hellboy 2 Review

David - I mention you in the review:

http://www.filmgecko.com/hellboy-ii-the-golden-army-review/

BLACK SHEEP REVIEWS THE DARK KNIGHT

Written by Jonathan Nolan and Christopher Nolan
Directed by Christopher Nolan
Starring Christian Bale, Heath Ledger, Aaron Eckhart, Michael Caine, Gary Oldman, Maggie Gyllenhaal and Morgan Freeman


Alfred Pennyworth: Some men simply want to watch the world burn.

There can only be one Batman and as I sat amongst a full crowd that was silent in awed anticipation at the crack of the film, it is clear that director, Christopher Nolan’s Batman is the one. In BATMAN BEGINS, Nolan (whom at the time he attempted to revive the franchise had only directed a handful of indie projects) took an icon and made him human. Batman, and of course his real life persona, Bruce Wayne, was damaged. He had fears; he had frustrations; he had to find himself. What he found with a little push from Nolan was a flawed figure but also a man whose heroism was defined by his humility and relentless pursuit of justice for those incapable of demanding it for themselves. With the arrival of THE DARK KNIGHT, Nolan has finished with his foundation and taken to the vertigo-inducing heights on the tallest of Gotham’s buildings to analyze the city and all its inhabitants. Gliding both gracefully and dauntingly through all of it is the dark knight himself (reprised by third time Nolan collaborator, Christian Bale). What he sees from his unique view that becomes our privileged spectacle is world of delineating lines and order that is about to torn apart by chaos and chance.


Gotham City must be pretty far down the list of safest places in America to live. Not only does there seem to be nightly violence at the hands of common street thugs but all the crazies seem to end setting up shop there too. Enter the Joker (Heath Ledger). We know nothing of what made him the homicidal maniac he is nor does he have any regard for human life. In fact, he has nothing but disdain for it. Humanity’s rules and order may disgust him but they also make it possible for him to predict how people will behave, allowing him the chance to throw out loops to throw them off and laugh at their expense. The Joker is frightening enough in concept but Ledger’s performance is down right terrifying. As he constantly licks his lips with self-assured cynicism, he cuts to the chase in every scenario. He has no time for any games other than the ones he orchestrates himself and commands control everywhere he goes. His idea of playing always involves games with the ultimate consequence and the highest of stakes. In order to win these games, you must reject what you know and become everything you denounce. Only winners will know the rewards of living both sides of the coin and the Joker is counting on fear to prevail so that he can finally have someone to play with.


Along with his brother, Jonathan, Nolan has crafted a dark, twisted dissection of duality and morality that is often shocking, unexpected and intricately detailed. In every superhero tale, everyone always wants to know the man behind the mask. The mask itself, the creation of another persona other than the one that sits safely behind it, initiates the duality that permeates the notion of the superhero figure. Batman is the dark knight. He only comes out at night and no one would suspect the man he is by day might be one and the same. The Joker’s chaos theory ruptures Batman’s controlled existence and forces him to think in a darker fashion than he has ever had to before. Thinking that darkly though can leave you stranded in that space and this is what the Joker is counting on. What makes THE DARK KNIGHT so rich is that almost every character has conflict and questions their actions and motivations. No answer is the clear right answer and deceit seems to play a role in even the most well-intentioned decisions. The greatest irony is that the darkest character actually has the purest of souls while the would be clown seems to have no soul at all. This is perhaps what makes them such worthy adversaries and why they both almost seem to enjoy the challenge.


When THE DARK KNIGHT feels like it might be ending, the anxiety mounts because you won’t want it to end. It has an enormous scope but is somehow still subtle. It is incredibly complex but yet still simple. The film itself is steeped in just as much duality as its hero. Nolan never loses control of his dualistic duty – to create a Batman film that pleases both the masses and the fans, that encompasses the grandness of a blockbuster with the darkness of the independent spirit and wows without resorting to cheap tricks. Once again, Nolan has grounded the sensational on a very firm footing by never allowing Batman to be anything other than a man. We can then stand on the same level ground as the giant bat and feel a satisfaction that is both real and incredible.

GRADE: A

Revised list of Best of 2007

  1. There Will Be Blood
  2. No Country For Old Men
  3. 300
  4. Michael Clayton
  5. Eastern Promises
  6. Superbad
  7. Lake of Fire
  8. Juno
  9. I Am Legend
  10. Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street

Ranking the 2008 movies so far

I posted this list on my WTHR blog. Thought I'd post it here too:

  1. The Dark Knight
  2. WALL-E
  3. Iron Man
  4. The Incredible Hulk
  5. Harold and Kumar Escape from Guantanamo Bay
  6. Forgetting Sarah Marshall
  7. The Spiderwick Chronicles
  8. Hellboy 2: The Golden Army
  9. Dr. Seuss's Horton Hears a Who!
  10. Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull
  11. The Ruins
  12. Kung Fu Panda
  13. Cloverfield
  14. 21
  15. Hancock
  16. Semi-Pro
  17. Sex and the City
  18. The Happening
  19. Jumper
  20. Meet the Spartans
  21. Untraceable
  22. 10,000 BC
  23. Speed Racer

Saturday, July 19, 2008

Jane's Dark Knight review

Here.

Jane seemed to have liked "Dark Knight" as much as I did but she thought it was too long. I disagree. I really could've taken more if Christopher Nolan wanted to give it. I was pretty sucked in the whole time. I think length can be a real problem with many of these event, big-budget, Summer franchises. ("Spider-Man 3" and the last two "Pirates of the Caribbean" movies come to mind.) Really I only think length is usually a problem if the film's themes can't sustain it. Spider-Man and Pirates were just excessive but had they been as deep as Dark Knight their length would have been acceptable. Instead they were just popcorn and after awhile all the action and special effects just got boring. It's kind of like if you get a big bag of one flavor of life savers. You'll enjoy it for awhile but by the time you get to the bottom of the bag you're sick of it and ready for another flavor. What's the solution? Get a bag of candy with a half dozen or even a dozen flavors. That's basically what "The Dark Knight" is. Agree? Disagree?

Black Sheep Talks WALL-E and Hello Dolly

This is a nice post.

Great job here, Black Sheep. You've written a nice piece about "WALL-E." I really like the angle you took with it. Just fantastic. Everyone should be sure and check it out. :-)

Cine Snob's review of The Dark Knight

Here.

He gave it a B+ and appears not to have been quite as impressed as I. (I just finished my review and will probably be submitting it later today or tomorrow.)

I really think "The Dark Knight" is the best superhero film not only of the summer but yet made. (I make the case for this in my review.) Agree? Disagree? Which film in the genre is better and why?

Anthony's Review of "Inside Man"

Here.

Anthony, it's so ironic that you wrote about "Inside Man" just recently. It's one of my favorites of the past few years and one I own and seen multiple times. I was just thinking about it the other day when I ran into one of my bosses in the men's room at work. We made the usual chit chat and started talking about movies. He said how much he liked Denzel Washington and I insisted that he check out "Inside Man." (I might bring it in for him to borrow sometime.)

One of the things about the film that I like the most is that it's so different than any other film Spike Lee has made. It's his first thriller and genre picture. All of his other films are either a drama, comedy, or documentary. It's nice for well known directors to step out of their comfort zones and usual territory because it really shows the pure filmmaker within. Another example of this idea in a different film is David Cronenberg with his recent Eastern Promises. (I mention it in my review here.)

Your point about film as a timeless art is also important. Recently my editor gave me a blog so I could write DVD reviews and thoughts on older films. I really love having it. My most recent post ranks the films of 2008 that I've seen so far. Right now The Dark Knight is at the top, followed by WALL-E and Iron Man.

Friday, July 18, 2008

Just saw The Dark Knight...

... and was totally blown away. I'm planning an A+ review... Saw it on IMAX too. It was sold out and we had to wait in a long line to get into the theatre. (We'd bought our tickets a week ago online.) It was like waiting in line for an amusement park ride. In my review I plan to focus on the theme in the film of Batman being representative of authoritarianism and the Joker being anarchy.

Movies Are Timeless Works of Art

Like many other critics, I love to watch films and summarize my thoughts in writing. However, this is something I do as a hobby, not a professional career. Because of this, I cannot watch every single new release and review them in time for others to read. Hell, I'm still trying to gather a loyal readership. Therefore, I'm not the kind of person to go to for my thoughts on the latest release. For example, you will not find a review of The Dark Knight at Anthony's Film Review this opening weekend. I'm just not in a position to review all new films.

At first, this seems like a major drawback, but the more I think about it, the more I accept this limitation and am comfortable with the idea of being a retrospective film critic. Yes, I will review a newly released movie if I happen to see it, but if not, I find older films to write about.

Basically, I want to remind everyone that movies are timeless works of art. You can enjoy a movie on opening day or fifty years after it. A few friends have read what I've written and proceeded to rent some older movies based on my reviews. That's how I discovered that it's just as fun to review an older movie as much as a newer one. After all, there are so many movies that we've missed that retrospective reviews can remind us what passed us by.

So I may not have reviewed The Dark Knight, but I did review Inside Man. Yes, it came out in 2006, but I rented it recently and have shared my thoughts for anyone who's curious about it. Once again, movies are timeless works of art. If you keep that in mind, film criticism will always be inspiring.

Thursday, July 17, 2008

FilmCritic.com

Do you guys know about this site? I think I just email and asked to be added, and I see I'm on the list now (the very bottom, but I'll take it!)

http://www.filmcritic.com/misc/emporium.nsf/reviews/links

j.

Tuesday, July 15, 2008

Hellboy 2 review

http://www.wthr.com/Global/story.asp?S=8676625

I think it came out well.

Monday, July 14, 2008

Saturday, July 12, 2008

Hellboy 2

I just got back from seeing "Hellboy 2" and am getting ready to write my review. Right now I'm planning on an A-. I'll post the link once it's written and on the WTHR site. What did you guys think? Would anyone who wrote about it like to post the link to their review and maybe talk about it?

Wednesday, July 9, 2008

The Many Styles of Film Criticism

All film critics, professional and otherwise, represent a variety of styles in writing and discussing a film. A film scholar, for instance, would describe all elements of a film in detail. Others may summarize half of the plot and say whether it's good or not. Then there are those critics who just give you the bottom line about a movie.

For me, my style of film criticism involves more of the bottom line. I don't necessarily go into detail of every element of a film. Rather, I focus on the parts that stand out. For example, a movie may be best described as one with plenty of character development but barely any plot to stir up interest, or another movie that is meant to be a comedy spends too much time with lame unoriginal jokes. My reviews are at least five paragraphs long and focus on the one or two things from the movie that stand out. Then I seal it with a bottom-line 1-through-10 rating.

In my opinion, there really is no wrong way to review a movie. The important thing is to find a style that works for you and stick with it. That way, the reader recognizes your style and identifies you with it.

Tuesday, July 8, 2008

My "Hancock" review

http://www.wthr.com/Global/story.asp?S=8627262&nav=menu188_8_1

Sunday, July 6, 2008

My film critic story

Hey everyone I thought I'd share a little bit about where I come from as far as film criticism goes. I first started writing reviews when I was in high school (Carmel, IN '98-'02) for the school paper. I started off just kind of writing reviews and then became the entertainment editor in charge of the reviews. (I had a wonderful co-editor who handled the entertainment features.) I even won a high school journalism award for one of my reviews (of my favorite film, "Requiem for a Dream.") It was an Indiana High School Press Harvey Award, first place for opinion/review writing.

When I went to college at Ball State University in Muncie, IN (from '02- '06) I majored in English (creative writing emphasis) and Political Science and started as an op/ed columnist for the Ball State Daily News. After a few semesters I managed to snag the film critic spot as well. My senior year a friend forwarded me an e-mail that one of the execs at WTHR, the Indy NBC TV affiliate, had sent out to communications departments at Indiana colleges. The station was seeking college film critics for its web site for which it was starting to develop original content. I was the first of a group of four or five college-age critics to write reviews for the site. (If you look at the WTHR page with the movie reviews many of the ones near the bottom are by other Indiana college students.)

Eventually -- not quite sure why or how -- I became the station's sole critic, and started writing a review each week. (This was a little over a year ago.) A few months ago I also received a film blog for me to post miscellaneous movie thoughts. In addition to film reviews I've written two story series for the website, one on blogging and another on the book trend of the "new atheists" and the clash between fundamentalists and atheists.

It is a GREAT writing gig. The pay is nice (not enough to live on but a nice supplement,) my editor is very friendly and supportive, I can review whatever I want, I have no word limit, and no deadline. With my blog I can write about anything movie-related that interests me.

I view my film criticism as one third of my writing life. The other two legs are my fiction and nonfiction projects. Right now fiction-wise I've been working on the first novel of what I'd like to be a series. It's an epic fantasy novel for the young adult age group. I'm not generally a fantasy fanatic really but I had the idea and I've been running with it for about a year and a half now. For my nonfiction writing I'm in the planning and research phase right now on a book. The research can be found on my book blog and it would basically be based off of something I began with my senior political science thesis. I'm something of a political junky so if anyone enjoys that subject as well then it's another thing I'm always enthusiastic to discuss.

As far as what you might want to know about me personally... I'm engaged and will be getting married sometime in the next year and a half. My fiancee, April, sometimes makes appearances in my reviews and accompanies me to all the movies I review. I pay the bills by working full time as a collector for Sallie Mae. She works there too when she's not in school. (She has a year left at Ball State, then we're moving for grad school.) It's an interesting job that I enjoy more than I would've expected. Eventually I'd like to be able to write full time.

So what about you guys? What are your stories?

Saturday, July 5, 2008

Black Sheep's Top 10

Top 10 lists are so subjective and leave out so many good films but they are so much fun to make. I can't resist! So here is mine, in alphabetical order. Let's be honest though, it could probably change by next weekend ...

A bout de souffle (Breathless), Jean-Luc Godard (1960)
American Beauty, Sam Mendes (1999)
Annie Hall, Woody Allen (1977)
Brokeback Mountain, Ang Lee (2005)
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Michel Gondry (2004)
The Graduate, Mike Nichols (1967)
Pulp Fiction, Quentin Tarantino (1994)
Ratatouille, Brad Bird (2007)
Todo sobre mi madre (All About my Mother), Pedro Almodovar (1999)
West Side Story, Robert Wise & Jerome Robbins (1961)

Fairly eclectic, mostly contemporary ... that's me.

Youssef Kdiry's Top 10 Movies

(In no particular order)

STAR WARS
JAWS
THE GODFATHER
DIE HARD
THE EXORCIST
BLOODSPORT
HALLOWEEN
SATURDAY NIGHT FEVER
SCARFACE
THE EMPIRE STRIKES BACK

Friday, July 4, 2008

Yes, I love P.T. Anderson...get off my back

Top 12 (in no particular order)

1. Magnolia
2. Boogie Nights
3. There Will Be Blood
4. One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
5. American Beauty
6. Schindler's List
7. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
8. Talk to Her
9. L.A. Confidential
10. Fargo
11. Pulp Fiction
12. Shawshank Redemption

Why not just jump into it?

Hey guys, I figured we could either talk about it or do it. So for the time being I just created this blog so we could start chatting about films and our writing. Maybe in the future someone who's a bit more tech savvy than I might want to create a better site. It's basically free game as far as I'm concerned, I'm not electing myself moderator or chairman or anything. Post whatever you want. Ask whatever questions you want. If you want to do introductions then that's fine. I don't have time to write mine right now. To start the discussion, though, how about top 10 favorite film lists?

Here's mine:
  1. Requiem for a Dream
  2. Crumb
  3. El Topo
  4. If...
  5. The Last Temptation of Christ
  6. Fargo
  7. Malcolm X
  8. Before Night Falls
  9. Jackie Brown
  10. Trainspotting